or

Play the MobIncentive Fame Game, become famous, win $100

What is this?

This is an expired MobIncentive challenge. Contributions and solutions have been closed, and it is currently awaiting judgement.
1915
fame points

Get Taiwan into United Nations (Expired)

$171
Taiwan is a democratic, peace-loving country with 23 millions of people (ranked 49 in the world) but without UN representation. Taiwan has applied for the membership many times, but was repeatedly denied.

The incentive here is to seek workable solutions to this dilemma. The top three solutions will be selected and announced on or about September 5 every year just before the opening of the UN General Assembly. The selection is to be administered jointly by the World Taiwanese Association and the Department of Foreign Affairs of the Taiwan government. The cash incentive will be distributed to the top three winners equally and new cash incentive is to be raised every year every year until Taiwan becomes a member of the UN.

Tags (add): taiwan (1)   united nations (1)  




Add
Rating:  (5.00)
view contributions

Solutions

Solution #1 submitted by LOVETAIWAN on Aug-1-2007
Solution #2 submitted by Ryan Omori on Aug-5-2007
Solution #3 submitted by Ryan Omori on Aug-5-2007
How will this idea be judged? The incentive here is to seek workable solutions to this dilemma. The top three solutions will be selected and announced on or about September 5 every year just before the opening of the UN General Assembly. The selection is to be administered jointly by the World Taiwanese Association and the Department of Foreign Affairs of the Taiwan government. The cash incentive will be distributed to the top three winners equally and new cash incentive is to be raised every year every year until Taiwan becomes a member of the UN.

Comments (add a comment)

Please Login


Login
OR
OR
Comment Anonymously



Please pass a simple Turing Test.




No HTML please...



or


URL to a video or picture from YouTube, Flickr, PhotoBucket, etc...

Submit


Added by Clinton on 8/7/2007 8:23:02 AM Rating: 1
On July 27, 2007, in the UN Secretary General’s press encounter with California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger, Secretary General Ban made the following remark: “The Resolution (#2758) that you just mentioned is clearly mentioning that the Government of China is the sole and legitimate Government and the position of the United Nations is that Taiwan is part of China”. (http://www.un.org/apps/sg/offthecuff.asp?nid=1053. Of the 176 words in Resolution 2758, no word mentions “Taiwan”. What UN documents specify “Taiwan is part of China”? Mr. Ban has been hearing this unilateral statement by the People’s Republic of China (PRC) a thousand times and accepting it as a truth. If you look into the Shanghai Communiqué announced on February 28, 1972 between the US and China, there are many unilateral claims by the PRC in Item #11 regarding Taiwan. But the word the US carefully selected to use in Item #12 is “acknowledge”; in other words, the US acknowledges that it has received the PRC signal. There is a huge difference between “I hear what you say” and “I agree with what you say”. Unfortunately, Mr. Ban’s remark in July 2007 in California was to indicate that “I agree with what you say” but without legal basis. Ironically, Mao of the Communist China stated in 1930s that "We will extend [the Korean people] our enthusiastic help in their struggle for independence. The same thing applies to Formosa." (see Hsiao, Frank; and Sullivan, Lawrence, "The Chinese Communist Party and the Status of Taiwan, 1928-1943". Pacific Affairs 52 (3): 455-467, 1979.). But the Communist China changed their view on Taiwan 180 degrees after they acquired power in 1949. Does “power tends to corrupt, absolute power corrupts absolutely” ring a bell?
Solution Submitted on 8/5/2007 9:56:25 PM
Ryan Omori submitted a solution. Click here to rate the solution or add comments.
by pure luck
Added by anonymous on 8/5/2007 9:26:49 PM Rating: 0
It's goog for Taiwan.
Added by Eastwood on 8/5/2007 4:35:17 PM Rating: 1
Do you know the President of Taiwan was barred from visiting the US for more than 20 years? Now the US Congress is considering lifting all restrictions imposed on the visits by the Taiwanese highest-level government officials to the U.S --
In an unprecedented move, and with unanimous consent, the House Foreign Affairs Committee passed, on June 26, 2007, the House Concurrent Resolution (HCR) 136 led by Rep. Steve Chabot, calling for the lifting of all restrictions imposed on the visits by the Taiwanese highest-level government officials to the U.S, including the President. The HCR 136 was concurred by the Congress on July 30, 2007 and passed to the US Senate on July 31, 2007. ( to see HCR136, go to http://thomas.loc.gov; , click "bill number" radio button and enter HCR136)
Before 1986, Taiwan was a politically backward, authoritarian state living under the cloud of martial law and serious human rights abuses. In the matter of a few short decades, it made a remarkable transition to a full-fledged democracy with a vibrant economy and a vigorous multi-party political system with its president directly elected by the people. In spite of its praise for democracy in Taiwan, the United States Government continues to adhere to guidelines from the 1970s that bar the President, Vice President, Premier, Foreign Minister, and Defense Minister of Taiwan from coming to Washington, DC. HCR 136, passed by the House of Representatives, is a resolution to lift these restrictions on visits to the United States by high-level elected and appointed officials of Taiwan, including the democratically-elected President of Taiwan. We are happy that the US Congress is finally recognizing the fast progress of democracy in Taiwan. We need to get the US Government to wake up from the outdated, inadequate policies made during the 1970s and 1980s. Taiwan is really different now.
Solution Submitted on 8/5/2007 1:32:41 AM
Ryan Omori submitted a solution. Click here to rate the solution or add comments.
it was war that did the job
Added by Ryan Omori on 8/5/2007 1:28:29 AM Rating: 0
very niice
Solution Submitted on 8/1/2007 4:59:48 PM
LOVETAIWAN submitted a solution. Click here to rate the solution or add comments.
I love Taiwan, my club Taiwan, I support Taiwan.Taiwan originally for United Nations Council country, because but some country's from returns is compelled the withdrawal.
Taiwan originally for United Nations Council country, because but some country's from returns is compelled the withdrawal.Taiwan originally together organizes the country for the United Nations, because but some country's from returns is compelled.
Now, Taiwan from will return the United Nations by the national name, will not obtain many great nation supports, we will only be able from to return by own strength.Although does not have the great nation support, but has the Taiwan 23,000,000 people's supports, also has in the overseas many fellow countryman living abroad's support, we will succeed enter the United Nations, because, our Taiwan also will be world one.Refuels, the United Nations will have a seat will be Taiwan, will refuel Taiwan!

我愛台灣,我梃台灣,我支持台灣。台灣原為聯合國理事會國,但因某國的從返而被迫退出。台灣原為聯合國共同創辦國,但因某國的從返而被迫退出。現在,台灣將以國家名義從返聯合國,獲得不到許多大國的支持,我們只能以自己的力量從返。雖沒有大國的支持,但擁有台灣兩千三百萬人民的支持,也有在國外許多僑胞的支持,我們將成功進入聯合國,因為,我們台灣也是世界的一員。加油,聯合國將有一席位子是台灣的,加油台灣!
Added by Eastwood on 7/28/2007 7:39:57 PM Rating: 1
How does a piece of land change hand? For you and me to buy a house, we go to the owner, negotiate price, sign contract, and record the transaction in court. For a large piece of land like Alaska on a country-to-country level, we bought from Russia for $7.8 millions years ago; apparently, Russia was recognized by the US and the world as the owner of Alaska. The legal docuemnts must be in the US Congress and Russian's.
China and Japan had a war back in late 1890s. China lost it and the Treaty of Shimonoseki was signed in which Taiwan was ceded to Japan. From 1895 to 1947, Taiwan was ruled by Japan. Now, Japan lost in World War II after two atomic bombs were dropped. Genealissimo McArthur accepted Japan's surrender and ordered the soldiers of Genealissimo Chiang Kai-Shek to occupy Taiwan. San Fransisco Peace Treaty (http://www.taiwandocuments.org/sanfrancisco01.htm) was signed in 1951 in which Japan gave up Taiwan, but "to whom" was not specified. In 1949, PRC (People's Republic of China) was born in China, expelling ROC (Republic of China for which Chiang Kai-Shek was the leader) to soverignty-unspecified Taiwan. Until 1972, ROC was a permanent member of the Security Council in the UN. But then the UN General Resolution 2758 (http://www.everything2.com/index.pl?node_id=1508687) voted-in PRC to replace ROC; now PRC is a permanent member of the Security Council with the veto power. The UN appears to view PRC and ROC as exclusive, but the 23 million people of Taiwan is without representation in the UN. PRC is telling the world that Taiwan is a province in its territory. "How does the world view this claim" is an interesting question; the view by government and its people may not be always identical. But let's achieve one small step at a time -- How can the discussion of the Taiwan membership get into the agenda of the UN assembly?
Added by jayjay on 7/24/2007 2:02:11 PM Rating: 1
It seems like there is no way around China's veto. I don't think even having the US on Taiwan's side would help. You're almost better off trying to push for reform of the rules of the Security Council so that the permanent members don't get automatic veto. Supposedly that's what Kofi Annan was trying to do (http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/03/21/un.reform/index.html.
Added by Chris Bain on 7/22/2007 11:17:06 PM Rating: 0
China claims Taiwan is one of its territories, but does the rest of the world see it that way, as well? Does the UN see Taiwan as a Chinese territory?
Added by Eastwood on 7/19/2007 6:59:16 PM Rating: 1
This is a weblink which describes about why UN rejects Taiwan's application many times:
http://english.www.gov.tw/UN/index.jsp
Basically, China, a permanent member of the UN Security Council, "claims" Taiwan is its territory and aims 1000s of missiles at Taiwan to take over by force if necessary. The US, the most powerful democratic country in the world, does not support Taiwan's application of the UN membership either. Taiwan has diplomatic relation with only a handful of small countries.
Added by jayjay on 7/18/2007 6:28:25 PM Rating: 0
Can you provide some background as to why Taiwan has been denied membership?